Monica - Mattos The Infamous Horse Scene Bestiality
Yet, the pragmatic welfare advocate counters: "If we don't pass Proposition 12, 40 million pigs will spend their entire lives inside metal crates where they cannot even turn around. Your perfect rights morality saves zero of those pigs."
Bestiality, or sexual contact with animals, is illegal in many parts of the world. Laws vary by country and even by state or region within countries, but the consensus is that bestiality is a form of animal abuse. The inclusion of a horse in the scene with Monica Mattos raised concerns that the line between acceptable adult content and bestiality might have been blurred.
The question is not, "Can they reason?" nor, "Can they talk?" but, "Can they suffer?" And if the answer is yes—as it is for billions of creatures right now—then we have a moral obligation to change. Monica Mattos The Infamous Horse Scene Bestiality
Understanding the nuance between these two concepts is essential for any meaningful discussion on the topic. Animal Welfare: The "Humane Treatment" Standard
The arc of moral progress bends toward inclusion. We once said women, people of different skin colors, and people with different beliefs had no rights. We were wrong. History will look back on our industrial-scale slaughterhouses with the same horror we now feel for human slavery. Yet, the pragmatic welfare advocate counters: "If we
is a science-based and utilitarian approach. It accepts that humans will use animals for food, research, entertainment, and labor, but argues that we have a moral obligation to minimize the suffering involved in that use.
Science has caught up with ethics. We now know that fish feel pain. Cows have best friends and experience stress when separated. Chickens display complex problem-solving skills on par with young children. Pigs are more intelligent than domestic dogs. These are not automatons. They are someone , not something. The inclusion of a horse in the scene
For too long, the conversation about animals has stopped at pity. We see a stray dog shivering in the rain, and our hearts ache. We watch a video of a factory-farmed pig, and we feel a pang of guilt. But feeling sorry for animals is not enough. It never has been.
: The World Organisation for Animal Health (WOAH) sets international guidelines for welfare. Animal Rights and Animal Welfare: Find Your Own Sources