Conversely, mainstream Sunni scholars argue that this particular chain is flawed. Their critique focuses on one critical narrator: .
was a towering figure of Khurasan, a master of hadith criticism, and the chief judge (Qāḍī) of Nishapur. He belonged to the Shafi’i school of thought but was renowned for his relative independence in evaluating narrators. al-hakim al-mustadrak vol. 4 p. 398
Al-Hakim Al-Mustadrak, also known as "The Comprehensive Compilation of Hadith," is a vast collection of Prophetic traditions, Companion reports, and scholarly discussions. Completed in the 11th century CE, this magnum opus comprises four volumes, covering a wide range of subjects, including theology, jurisprudence, spirituality, and history. Al-Hakim Al-Naisaburi's meticulous approach to Hadith criticism and his expertise in Islamic jurisprudence have made this work an indispensable reference for scholars and researchers. He belonged to the Shafi’i school of thought
Before examining the page itself, one must understand the architect behind the work. The "Dhahabi" Check:
but were not included in their respective collections [20, 22]. The "Dhahabi" Check: